
From Houston Nutt to Bobby Petrino, huh? Boy, those guys from Arkansas seem to really want to avoid the court of public opinion.
You’d think the Arkansas Razorbacks would want to distance themselves from controversy when hiring a head coach for their football team after what they just went through with Houston Nutt.
But then they hired Bobby Petrino, and that whole idea went out the window.
So here’s the question: Did the Arkansas Razorbacks just jump out of the frying pan and into the fire when it comes to recruiting? The answer?
Keep reading.
Current Arkansas Razorbacks head coach Bobby Petrino possesses an overall college football head coaching record of 41-9. Quite impressive when you consider that he’s only put in time at the University of Louisville in this capacity. After all, the Cards history isn’t exactly one known for stellar football.
Before Louisville Petrino put in time as offensive coordinator and/ or quarterbacks coach at places like Idaho, Arizona State, Nevada, Utah State, Louisville (offensive coordinator), Auburn, and the Jacksonville Jaguars of the NFL. Thus, he certainly has an impressive resume.
But then you remember 2007 and the way he left the Atlanta Falcons before the season was even over. In fact, Petrino only notified his players via a piece of paper. Further, this isn’t the first time that Petrino’s actions could be considered somewhat suspect. Remember when he met secretly with Auburn brass several years earlier to talk about taking Tommy Tuberville’s job? That wouldn’t have been good in and of itself. But when you consider the fact that he actually coached under Tuberville at one point, at face value it looks downright terrible.
Then there’s Houston Nutt. The former Arkansas and current Ole Miss coach managed to achieve a 75-48 record while at the helm for the Hogs. In sum, anyone who believes that Nutt didn’t do anything positive while at Arkansas is living in a dream world.
Nutt’s the second winningest coach in Arkansas history. His teams won three SEC West titles. He also took home three SEC Coach of the Year trophies (the most recent in 2006) and was named Division I-A Coach of the Year by Sporting News in 1998.
Said another way, in the eight years prior to Nutt’s arrival, Arkansas was 38-51 with only two bowl bids. Need anything else be said?
But then a few Springdale kids decided to sign on with Nutt and the Razorbacks, one of which so happened to be the Parade Player of the Year in quarterback Mitch Mustain. In the end, Mustain and friends weren’t happy. They said that they were lied to on the recruiting trail where they claimed that they were told the offensive would change. Heck, their high school coach was even signed on as offensive coordinator furthering their he said she said argument.
But it was not to be. The offense didn’t change. And that sparked a heated controversy for Houston Nutt that just wouldn’t end. He was labeled a liar.
So let’s break this one down. The supposed lies to the Springdale Three- no one really knows whether Nutt lied or not beyond the people involved- is a bad transgression if true. In other words, if recruits believe that Nutt did lie then that wouldn’t have helped recruiting for sure. Then again, Arkansas did manage to gain commitments from 9 of the top 10 Arkansas state recruits this year, most of which were gained while Nutt was in charge. So did the problems really impact recruiting?
A little, but not terribly.
Then there’s what Petrino did. First, whereas what Nutt was accused of is debatable, the same cannot be said for the former Louisville coach. Fact: He walked out on the Atlanta Falcons in the middle of the season. Now we’re not privy to the conversations between Arthur Blank and he, but at face value that looks pretty bad. Then again, coaches get fired before the season is over all of the time. So how bad is it when it happens the other way around?
Debatable.
Here’s the part that isn’t debatable, though. He left letters in his players lockers announcing his decision. That’s right, he didn’t even talk to them about it. Now that can’t help recruiting at all, can it? Leaving your players with only a letter at your last job. That’s like dumping your girlfriend with a letter. Just not cool.
So when you look at the facts, and not just conjecture, what Petrino did looks worse. Further, Nutt was beginning to pick up some steam again on the recruiting trail and in the court of public opinion with the Hogs victory over LSU.
Guess what, though? None of this matters. Here’s why.
No one is going to remember any of this. Bobby Petrino has a great college track record. He’s a winner and runs a fun offense. The ninth rated prospect in Arkansas, quarterback Tyler Wilson, committed after he took over. Do you believe he was thinking about what Petrino did in Atlanta?
Nope. He was thinking about stats in a passer friendly offense and winning. In the end, despite all of the backlash regarding these two rather controversial coaches, it’s going to be about winning and the kind of club they have. Houston Nutt won with a stellar ground game at Arkansas, and running backs therefore liked to come play for him. Bobby Petrino is more of a pass happy guy. As long as he wins- and he will- all of these Atlanta shenanigans will disappear. Further, quarterbacks and receivers will want to play for this guy on reputation alone.
For now. Later, it will be about whether he wins or not.
So the answer regarding recruiting? It doesn’t matter. The past will disappear rather quickly. We live in a world of second chances (and third, and fourth, and fifth). In the end, Houston Nutt will continue to be a good recruiter at Arkansas. In the end, Bobby Petrino will do a very good job at Arkansas.
And the past will disappear. After all, it’s not like either of these guys were involved in dog fighting.